Knowledge, Belief and Truth

‘I come now to the definition of “knowledge.” As in the cases of “belief” and “truth,” there is a certain inevitable vagueness and inexactitude in the conception. Failure to realize this has led, it seems to me, to important errors in the theory of knowledge. Nevertheless, it is well to be as precise as possible about the unavoidable lack of precision in the definition of which we are in search.

It is clear that knowledge is a sub-class of true beliefs: every case of knowledge is a case of true belief, but not vice versa. It is very easy to give examples of true beliefs that are not knowledge. There is the man who looks at a clock which is not going, though he thinks it is, and who happens to look at it at the moment when it is right; this man acquires a true belief as to the time of day, but cannot be said to have knowledge. There is the man who believes, truly, that the last name of the Prime Minister in 1906 began with a B, but who believes this because he thinks that Balfour was Prime Minister then, whereas in fact it was Campbell-Bannerman. There is the lucky optimist who, having bought a ticket for a lottery, has an unshakeable conviction that he will win, and, being lucky, does win. Such instances can be multiplied indefinitely, and show that you cannot claim to have known merely because you turned out to be right.’

– Russell. B. (1912) The Problems of Philosophy

4 thoughts on “Knowledge, Belief and Truth

  1. Twain on knowledge and belief:

    “Faith is believing what you know ain’t so.”
    — Mark Twain —

  2. I love this Mark Twain parody:

    Dan: The best way to get revenge on these people is to use them to make a shitload of money. Mark Twain said that!
    – Veep (2015) Season 4, Episode 6; “Storms and Pancakes” [No. 34]

  3. This is just the tip of the iceberg. It appears that knowledge is a justified true belief . The “justified” part is to avoid the clock situations. Belief justification is somewhat tricky. Probabilism, reliabilism, evidentialism, internalism, externalism, deontology, Gettier problem. I don’t think I got to the bottom of it.

  4. Sadly, in the last years of his life, Twain (Clemens) not only lost his daughter, he lost much of his money due to bad investments and turned very bitter, which was when he wrote “The Damned Human Race.”

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s